Two school cheerleaders, Kyler Quinn and Khloe Kapri, burst into the office of the school coach, Chad Alva. The cheerleaders demand to know which one of them is going to be given the head cheer position. Kyler and Khloe have each been getting private lessons from Coach Chad, so each one argues that she’s his favorite. Chad says this isn’t the right time to talk about this, but Kyler and Khloe both continue arguing.
As the two cheerleaders keep talking, it comes out that they’ve each been doing a lot more than just cheer practice with Chad during their private sessions. Chad tries again to end the discussion, but the cheerleaders insist that he needs to pick a favorite NOW. As both cheerleaders express their eagerness to be the one who pleases him the most, Chad relents, saying he’ll have to compare the cheerleaders side-by-side to see who is the better lover. Neither cheerleader wants to back down, so they both quickly and eagerly agree to prove themselves.
Chad has the two cheerleaders bend over his desk side-by-side, so he can finger both of their pussies at the same time and check whose hole is tighter. The comparisons continue thoughout various sex acts, including Chad eating out both of their pussies, having Kyler and Khloe each give Chad a blowjob, and Chad fucking Kyler and Khloe in both their vaginas and their assholes. Chad even has them compete over who can swallow the most of his cum by cumming in Kyler’s mouth and then enjoying the sight of the two cheerleaders cumswapping as they fight over his cum. Who will the winner be?